Baptist had been considered one of the better prospects in his class. MLB.com ranked him as the 29th-best international prospect, calling him one of the fastest and most exciting players available. He was clocked at 6.1 seconds in the 60-yard dash, his speed giving him the potential to not only be a weapon on the basepaths, but an excellent defensive center fielder. Baptist had displayed improvement in making contact and appeared to be a future leadoff man in New York.

He lived up to his billing in the Dominican Summer League in 2023. Baptist posted a .276/.427/.476 batting line in his 136 plate appearances, hitting two homers and three doubles while stealing 12 bases and drawing 25 walks. There were some warts as he was caught stealing six times and had 29 strikeouts, but he also displayed enough potential to be a prospect to watch.

Baptist is now attracting attention for a different reason. The length of his suspension remains unknown. It is also yet to be determined whether the Mets will look to terminate his contract due to his false representation. He could still be a worthwhile prospect if he is not too much older than he claims. However, even if he stays in the organization, his leash and developmental time will be much shorter.